Google Ads Competitive Metrics Using Murky Data to Increase CPC

Mar 5, 2019PPC

In the old days, everyone focused on average position to get a feel for how their ads competed against everyone else. Lots of people felt the #2 ad slot was the best option and used position-based bidding to focus on that spot. Obviously, you can’t have everyone be second, there has to be a first, third, etc. But even worse, this de-incentivized bidding for the top spot, which suppressed bids. Google’s stock swings on the average CPC going up over time, thus position-based bidding disappeared.

Fast forward a few years, Google started offering competitive metrics like Impression Share (IS), Lost IS due to Rank, Lost IS due to Budget. These were pretty helpful in diagnosing where you might have opportunity to grow a campaign by bumping up bids or budgets. It also shifts the discussion away from average position a bit. Maybe you were okay with your ads showing up 3rd, but you might not be okay with them only showing up 40% of the time. Better spend more!

Average position is now this…

More recently, the SERP has grown ever-more complex with increases in knowledge panel style results, shopping ads, local local local and all sorts of additional paid and organic experiences. Average position is legitimately less useful than ever, as there could be only one text ad above the fold. Thus showing up 2nd could mean you’re not even on page 1. IS is still a valid metric, but maybe less perfect due to all the variations in SERP layout. So Google introduced Top IS and Absolute Top IS. Top IS is essentially your above-the-fold rate with Absolute Top IS being your first ad on the page rate. Absolute Top IS feels like an ego metric, but the gap between that and Top IS is a good measure of how much room to grow a given campaign or keyword has.

But now we have Click Share. When I first saw this metric announced, my instinct was it would be kind of like clickthrough rate, but only for ads. Basically, (your clicks / all ad clicks for your impressions). That could be useful, but might give away more data than Google would like about exactly how popular ads are. But no, it’s a measure of your clicks vs how many clicks you potentially could have gotten, maybe. It’s an estimate. To me, this just feels like a way to encourage higher bids. If your click share is low, there’s really no clear way to know why, but you’re missing out on clicks! So you are told to increase bids (spend more), improve quality score (generally spend more), add more extensions (spend more).

That’s kind of the point of all of these competitive metrics, but this one feels the least helpful for the advertiser. The impression-based metrics give a much more concrete and factual view of how your ads are performing and where there is room to grow. The fact that this is based on a mysterious model makes it simply feel like a carrot to encourage more spend and provide little or unclear insight.

Maybe someone out there has a different view, I’d love to hear it!

SEO Site Migrations – Development Phase

Listen to the experts discuss.

Understanding and Leveraging Keyword Bias in SEO Strategy

Keyword bias and bias in general tends to be seen as taboo. Typically we hear “bias” and think that it’s likely something that is clouding our judgment unfairly and therefore not allowing us to make sound judgments. These biases can be something that clouds our minds...

SEO Site Migrations – Planning Phase

Listen to the experts discuss.

MozCon 2024 Recap

Listen to the experts discuss.

The Google Leak

Listen to the experts discuss.

Google Expands AI in Search: What Marketers Need to Know

Table of Contents How will AI Overviews Impact User Behavior? How to Change Your SEO Strategy for AI Overview? How to Leverage Your Search Agency for Success It’s finally happening. Google is launching AI Overviews in its live search results. What was previously...

Why Does Everyone Hate SEO?

Listen to the experts discuss.

Google’s Next Spam Update

Listen to the experts discuss.

Short Videos Feature in Google

Listen to the experts discuss.

SEO Content Optimization: 3 Easy Steps to Get You Organic Visibility!

Search Engine Optimization (SEO) involves a wide variety of tactics for web owners and marketers to elevate their organic presence. One of the most common and most important SEO tactics is SEO Content Optimization. Most folks know that their content needs to be ideal...

What do you think? Share your thoughts below.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Want to learn even more cool stuff? Jay Ratkowski can help!

Reach out today! We’re happy to help talk more about whatever search marketing issue is keeping you up at night.