Help! Keywords Are Driving Traffic but Not Ranking

Jan 24, 2020 | SEO

Google Featured Snippet Algorithm Update

On January 23, Google announced that they have removed (globally implemented January 22) duplicate site listings shown in featured snippets. So if you had a featured snippet and a result showing in the 3rd position, that 3rd position rank will be no longer showing and your site will only be listed in the featured snippet. Goodbye “Position 0”. With this update, Google stated that this is a change to help with deduplication and allow for other potentially topic-relevant webpages to rank on the first page.

At this time deduplication will not effect video featured snippets, knowledge panel or top stories. Google’s SearchLiaison Twitter account tweeted:

“Deduplication does not happen for video featured snippets. It does for a featured snippet-variant that may resemble a Knowledge Panel on desktop, to the right side of results. This will likely stop later this week and resume when those move inline with main results…

“Deduplication does not happen with other features, such as Top Stories or Interesting Finds. Deduplication also only happens for the exact URL in the featured snippet and only within the first page of results”

According to Google this update will not affect rankings and results on Google Search Console. They stated that featured snippets have always been counted as the #1 position in its reporting.

“Why Are Keywords With No Rank Driving Traffic?”

Google Search Console reporting shouldn’t be affected by this deduplication change; however, most 3rd-party tool reporting will be directly impacted by this change. Earlier this week our team noticed that one of our client’s had a blog post with a featured snippet but the rank had changed – not only changed but that we were no longer in the top 100 results.The screenshot below shows how one of our daily-rank tracking tools is showing keywords that have a featured snippet but no longer show on the first page.

Google's deduplication update is effect 3rd party rank tracking tools - January 2020

If all of a sudden you’re asking yourself, “Why are keywords with no rank driving so much traffic” or “why are all my biggest traffic-generating keywords not ranking” – you can blame deduplication!

If you do monthly keyword reporting, make sure to note that these keywords have not in fact been removed from SERPs but that the change is due to Google’s deduplication efforts.

Featured Snippet Strategy Changes

The question now becomes, what next? Should our keyword/topic research or strategy change? Do we want to be in the featured snippet or is best to be in the new position 2 (previously position 1)? How will deduplication change my organic traffic numbers?

In general, I don’t think overall strategy changes. We need more data before we start making strategic decisions on whether or not to target featured snippets. At this point, we know that featured snippets drive traffic. People read them and seem to trust them, so we should shoot to be visible there whenever possible. It is going to be crucial to watch how traffic and ranks change over the coming and weeks and months to really determine how this change is going to affect our clients in the long-term.

Cloudflare’s New AI Bot Controls

Overview Cloudflare replaced its single "Block AI Bots" toggle with three separate traffic categories — Search, Agent, and Training — available to every customer, including Free plan. Beginning September 15, 2026, Cloudflare is changing how these controls work,...

Google Store: A Helpful Content Horror Story

A fun discovery was posted by Matt Smith on X the other day.Oh good, Google Store is now publishing health content and outranking MayoClinic, ClevelandClinic, Healthline, and other health websites on weight loss topics. What could go wrong. Have you seen this before?...

Analysis of AI Chatbot Referrals

Kevin Indig did a great roundup of AI Chatbot referrals over at Search Engine Journal. The data in his article comes from Similarweb, which is sort of like Nielsen for websites. Calling out some of the highlights here with thoughts. AI Traffic is Insignificant as a...

Should ChatGPT be a Dominant Traffic Source?

SEJ just published an article about brands saying they're getting increased traffic from LLM chatbots. This included some very impressive stats. Viv, a period care brand, noticed a trend last summer when its website traffic increased by400%. Marketing director Kelly...

INBOUND 2024 Recap: Resilience & Opportunity

Listen to the experts discuss.

SEO Integration: How SEO Impacts Other Marketing Channels

Digital marketing is more important than ever now that everyone is staying at home. Learn how SEO can be incorporated into other marketing channels and boost your business!

Going International: Multilingual SEO Guide & Best Practices

Table of Contents What is Multilingual SEO? Defining Your Multilingual Strategy Content & Language Dexterity Technical SEO Considerations Tracking Analytics for Multilingual SEO Businesses grow and expand and in many cases that means international expansion....

A Competitor Rebrands: What Can You Do?

Taking Traffic During Moments of Opportunity In B2B SEO, seizing moments of opportunity can be the difference between staying ahead or falling behind. One of these moments popped up for a client of ours in the lease accounting software space. A leading competitor...

Magento SEO: Optimization, Tips, And Best Practices

Magento - also known as Adobe Commerce - is a “flexible and scalable commerce platform that lets you create uniquely personalized B2B and B2C experiences, no matter how many brands you have.” Magento is one of the most popular ecommerce platforms we encounter every...

The Disadvantages of SEO: Understanding Its Limitations and Who May Not Benefit

Table of Contents SEO Takes Time to Show Results High Competition can be a Barrier for SEO Uncertain and Changing Algorithms SEO is an Ongoing Investment SEO isn't for all Business Models ROI can be Hard to Measure SEO has Technical Complexities Search Engine...

Want to learn even more cool stuff? Transistor Team can help!

Reach out today! We’re happy to help talk more about whatever search marketing issue is keeping you up at night.

[hubspot type="form" portal="4545270" id="14f3e659-3bb6-4032-b293-dfcdd4f63e2e"]